5 Essential Financial Habits for Small Nonprofits and Creato

Source: Pexels

You already know that running a nonprofit doesn't mean that money stops mattering. You’re not aiming to generate profit, sure, but you still have bills to pay, people to compensate, and goals to reach. So yes, money always matters. This goes double if you're a creator or grassroots organizer, because more than likely, your project runs on a tiny budget (but comes with a lot of personal sacrifices).

The point is, just like for-profit organizations, you need a functional and transparent financial system in place. The only "small" issue is, you’re operating without the infrastructure of both a for-profit and a large nonprofit organization. You don’t have a CFO. Heck, you might not even have a bookkeeper.

Nevertheless, if you want your organization to succeed, you have to find a way to stay financially healthy. So how do you accomplish this?

Create a Budget That Works With You

Your budget should be grounded in your mission, so start by defining what's really worth spending money on. Don't be wishy-washy here but specific: look at your fixed costs (platform subscriptions, software, potential payroll) and recurring vendor fees. Then, consider your historical data.

For example, you can look at how much your last fundraiser cost and what you actually brought in. Again, don’t guess, but be specific. If you ran a campaign in 2023 and it raised $5,200 from 86 donors, use that benchmark to shape your 2025 goals.

While you want to be as clear and specific here, it's also wise to build in space for flexibility. After all, most grassroots work and creative projects tend to attract unexpected opportunities, but also many surprises. 

Separate Personal from Project Accounts

If you're swiping your own card for project costs without documentation or running donations into your personal bank account, please stop. That "strategy" is a liability.

Instead, get a business checking account (even if you're not incorporated because many banks allow this with a DBA) and keep personal expenses out of project budgets entirely. Importantly, you should also set up a system for tracking income and expenses from the start. It can be as simple as it gets, it doesn't matter. What matters is you're transparent - this will help with your supporters and can help you if you ever apply for grant funding.

Keep Donors in the Loop with Clean, Clear Receipts

We already mentioned transparency and we'll do it again because it's essential for trust. And nothing says “we’ve got our act together” like a detailed donation receipt. It's better than “thank you for your donation.” Here, you want to include your nonprofit’s name, the amount donated, the date, and whether the donation is tax-deductible. Don't worry, you don’t need to buy expensive software to do this. You can use a free invoicing solution to send professional and branded receipts.

Treat Your Transaction Records Like Public Documents

You may think that because you're a small nonprofit, you don't have to file detailed annual reports. Now, while you may not technically have to (yet), it's best to act like you are. In other words, keep all income, expenses, and reimbursement records organized, ideally in a cloud-based system that multiple team members can access if needed.

For this to work best, use descriptive labels for every transaction. To give you an example, a “Payment to contractor for video editing on Nov 6” is much more helpful than a “project expense.”

While you can use software for this (QuickBooks, Wave, and Zoho Books, to mention a few), know that even a locked-down Google Sheet can get the job done, as long as it’s updated consistently and someone is responsible for reviewing it monthly.

Forget Hope and Make Fundraising Forecasts Based on Reality

Listen, hopes and dreams are good; they're probably big reasons why you started your nonprofit. But when it comes to finance, it's best to forget about how you want your campaign to go and instead focus on reality, or how past ones actually performed.

You want to build your funding projections from donor retention rates, average gift sizes, and actual campaign performance. According to some research, recurring donors give 42% more annually than one-time donors, yet most grassroots campaigns fail to prioritize recurring gift options. Don't make this mistake yourself. Instead, look at your donor base and identify patterns. Do they respond to direct outreach best? Are your social posts converting to actual donations? Again, please don’t guess, but be specific: review the data and adjust the strategy accordingly.

Wrapping Up

It may be tempting to treat your nonprofit finances casually; after all, you're not looking to generate profit, so what's the fuss? In reality, all organizations - small nonprofits included - need to treat their financial system responsibly. Otherwise, you won't be able to serve your mission.

So, think of your financial habits as your foundation (because that's what they really are), not just an administrative chore. The more organized and transparent your back-end is, the easier it is to build trust, apply for grants, collaborate with others, and, most importantly, keep going.